Table of Contents

Cold toes at first light, a boot that soaks through by noon or a slip on an icy creek crossing can end a hunt early. That is why hunters shopping Irish Setter boots often look at ours too: both brands build serious leather hunting boots, but they build them differently. Here is how Hillman hunting boots compare with what Irish Setter publishes about its own designs.

Pair of boots on wet grass next to a tree stump

Irish Setter vs. Hillman: Two Takes on the Leather Hunting Boot

Irish Setter, part of Red Wing Shoes, has made hunting boots since 1950. Our Aerogel 2.0 takes a newer approach to the same job, built around lightweight insulation and ice traction for late-season cold.

Point Hillman Aerogel 2.0 Irish Setter (per its own specs)
Leather Full-grain Italian cow leather with Dyneema Full-grain waterproof leather
Waterproofing Dryhunt PFAS-free membrane UltraDry waterproofing system
Insulation Aerogel plus Matrix Varies by model, some use 400g Thinsulate Ultra
Outsole Vibram Arctic Grip on a Vibram EVA midsole Varies by model
Widths Regular (D) and Wide (EE) Varies by model

Leather and Waterproofing

Leather is where a hunting boot earns its keep. Ours uses full-grain Italian cow leather reinforced with Dyneema, so the upper stands up to scuffs from rock and deadfall. Inside, the PFAS-free Dryhunt membrane keeps the boot waterproof.

Irish Setter describes its boots as full-grain waterproof leather built around its UltraDry waterproofing system, with Goodyear leather welt construction on many styles. Both are proven ways to keep water out. The better question is how the boot handles the cold once you stop walking.

Break-in matters with any leather boot. Wear new boots around the house and on a few short hikes before opening day, so the leather shapes to your foot before a long day in the field does it the hard way.

Warmth, Traction and Fit

Warmth is where the two brands separate most. Hillman's Aerogel 2.0 combines Aerogel and Matrix insulation, a lightweight pairing, so you are not hauling heavy insulation up every ridge. Pair them with merino socks rather than cotton, since damp cotton undoes any insulation.

Underfoot, the Vibram Arctic Grip outsole is built for traction on wet ice, on a shock-absorbing Vibram EVA midsole.

Fit comes in two widths, Regular (D) and Wide (EE). If standard boots pinch across the forefoot, our wide hunting boots give you the same build with more room. Irish Setter's insulation and outsoles vary by model, so check each style's specs against the conditions you hunt.

Which Hillman Hunting Boots Fit Your Hunt

Our simple tip: buy the boot for your coldest, iciest day, not your easiest one. If you sit late-season stands, glass frozen ridges or cross icy creeks, start with our insulated leather hunting boots. Each pair carries a 2-year warranty against manufacturing and material defects. For warm early-season hunts, an insulated boot is more than you need, so pick a lighter, uninsulated waterproof boot and save the Aerogel pair for November.

Every serious hunter knows the feeling of numb toes on a late-season stand, so shop online with Hillman for leather hunting boots made for your coldest day afield.

Caleb Foster
Author

Caleb Foster

Technical Apparel & Hunting Materials Analyst

Caleb Foster analyzes hunting clothing from a technical perspective. Membranes, insulation systems, ventilation, durability and fabric behavior under movement are the details he studies most closely. His articles help hunters understand how technical gear performs beyond product specifications and marketing claims.

 Related blog posts

Early Season Whitetail Clothing: Stay Cool, Dry, Scent-Aware - HILLMAN USA

Early Season Whitetail Clothing: Stay Cool, Dry, Scent-Aware

Early season whitetail hunting requires lightweight, moisture-wicking synthetics or merino wool to pull sweat away from the skin and prevent odor buildup in warm weather. Packing outer camo layers for the walk-in prevents overheating on the approach, while breathable stretch pants and thin hoods protect against bugs and brush without restricting movement. Staying cool, dry, and bite-free allows hunters to sit still longer when deer start moving.

Read more: Early Season Whitetail Clothing: Stay Cool, Dry, Scent-Aware

Down Vs. Synthetic: Which Insulated Hunting Jacket Wins In The Backcountry? - HILLMAN USA

Down Vs. Synthetic: Which Insulated Hunting Jacket Wins In The Backcountry?

Choose down when the air is dry, the climb is long and pack weight decides how far you can go, because high-fill goose down gives the most warmth per ounce and packs into its own pocket. Choose synthetic when you will sweat hard, sit through sleet or hunt wet river bottoms, since its fibers keep insulating when damp. Moisture, more than temperature, is what should decide which jacket goes in your pack.

Read more: Down Vs. Synthetic: Which Insulated Hunting Jacket Wins In The Backcountry?

Irish Setter Vs. Hillman: Comparing Leather Hunting Boots - HILLMAN USA

Irish Setter Vs. Hillman: Comparing Leather Hunting Boots

Irish Setter, a Red Wing Shoes brand, leans on classic Goodyear-welted designs with its UltraDry waterproofing, while Hillman's Aerogel 2.0 pairs Italian leather and Dyneema with Aerogel insulation, Vibram Arctic Grip soles and steel-wire lacing. Both brands build full-grain leather hunting boots around a waterproof membrane, so the real differences show up in insulation, traction and fit. How cold, wet and icy your hunts get should decide which leather boot you buy.

Read more: Irish Setter Vs. Hillman: Comparing Leather Hunting Boots

FAQs

Are Irish Setter boots a good brand?

Irish Setter has a long track record: the brand, part of Red Wing Shoes, has made hunting boots since 1950. A brand name alone won't tell you whether a boot suits your hunt, though. Compare the specific model's leather, membrane, insulation and outsole against the temperatures and terrain you face, then try it on with the socks you hunt in.

How should leather hunting boots fit?

Leather hunting boots should lock your heel in place while leaving room to wiggle your toes in hunting socks. Try them on late in the day, when your feet are at their largest. Walk a slope or stairs in them before the season, because heel lift that feels minor in a store turns into blisters on a long climb.

How do you care for leather hunting boots?

Leather hunting boots last longest when you clean, dry and condition them after hard use. Brush off mud, pull the insoles and let the boots dry at room temperature, never next to a stove or heater. A leather conditioner applied a few times a season keeps the upper supple and helps it shed water.